search icon

Restaurants Near Mallory Square

First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery

American RestaurantsBrunch

First Flight offers premier outdoor dining in the heart of the historic Pan Am Airways headquarters. A true Key West experience like no other. Off the main red-bricked garden lies the Southernmost Brewery in the USA. The famous "Crash Bar," so named for the Sikorsky sea plane plunging through the ceiling, provides a unique drinking surface, located off the main garden. Stop by and try any 3 of their original brews on tap, in addition to serving lunch and dinner!

American RestaurantsLocal Seafood

Located on the exclusive Sunset Key, the perfect breakfast lunch or dinner is just a ferry ride away at Latitudes. Chef Todd uses locally sourced fish, tropical fish and ingredients to create and ever evolving menu that includes island favorites such as the pan-seared snapper with risotto or the Wagyu beef skirt steak crusted with honey and ancho with roasted garlic. Dine indoors or out with the sand between your toes.
A&B Lobster House

Seafood RestaurantsWaterfront Dining

Since 1947, the A&B Lobster House has been serving and providing the ultimate experience in luxurious seafood dining! Offering a selection of fine steaks, locally caught seafood and lobsters, the A&B Lobster House features a full wine menu for a perfect fusion of dining flavor. After dinner, sample the finest cognacs, dessert wines, handmade cigars and specially crafted martinis at a local’s bar—Berlin’s!
Hog’s Breath Saloon

American RestaurantsHappy Hour Bars

For 25 years, the Hog’s Breath Saloon has served cold drinks, delicious food and live music in their outdoor tropical setting and in the rustic, cool interior of the bar! “Hog’s breath is better than no breath at all!” Enjoy the cool, air -conditioned interior or have a drink outside! Check out their three live webcams or purchase one of their famous t-shirts in the mercantile store!

Ice Cream ShopsItalian Restaurants

If you’re a fan of real Italian pizza with crisp crusts and perfectly seasoned tomato sauce, or creamy cool gelato, then Duetto is the place for you. Offering the best pizzas, panini and gelato this side of Italy. Duetto iconveniently located just steps off of Duval Street, offers the most delicious Italian food this side of Rome for anyone craving a taste of Italy. Eat in, take out or call for delivery.
Bistro 245

American RestaurantsLocal Seafood

Enjoy casual dining inside or outside with breathtaking views of the Key West Harbor. Fresh pasta, Black Angus Beef and Key West shrimp are just a few favorites! Join them for Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner or their spectacular brunch that satisfies your every taste buds.
Garbo's Grill

BurgersOutdoor Seating

A absolute must stop on your vacation, this little food-truck-that-could is worth seeking out on Caroline Street for authentic island-style tacos and burritos. Owned and operated by a husband and wife team, they often have a line waiting to sample their popular cuisine. Although they do have a few spots where you can eat at on the Grunts Bar patio, their tasty dishes are mainly for take out.
Fogarty's Restaurant

American RestaurantsBurgers

A locals' favorite! Situated in the famous Fogarty House on the corner of Duval and Caroline Streets, this restaurant serves up healthy sized portions of great American fare and local seafood. Fogarty's famous outdoor patio is great for people watching. Don't forget to visit their well known Flying Monkey Bar for a fabulous frozen treat!
Alonzo’s Oyster Bar

Local SeafoodOutdoor Seating

Alonzo’s Oyster Bar offers casual waterfront dining overlooking the exciting Key West Bight. Alonzo’s features the largest selections oysters in Key West which can be shucked, baked, or batter dipped to your liking. In addition to their amazing selection of oysters, Alonzo’s menu features an extensive selection of seafood. Couple your meal with the perfect drink or choose from Alonzo’s extensive wine selection, full bar, and daily drink specials.

Ice Cream Shops

Hot days call for cold treats. Even better… cold treats with pure and high quality ingredients. Häagen-Dazs embraces this philosophy and as a result, serves some of the best ice cream, sorbet, and frozen yogurt possible! For 50 years, Häagen-Dazs has dedicated themselves to create the perfect ice cream. So try some at either of the Key West locations.
Smokin' Tuna Saloon

American RestaurantsSeafood Restaurants

The Smokin’ Tuna Saloon is the best place for good food and music. Offering a raw bar, a generous selection of starters, sandwiches, dinners, sides, and a full bar, this saloon is ideal to sit back, have a drink and listen to a broad variety of live music. As a regular venue for the Key West Songwriters’ Festival, you will never hear a bad tune here. Tucked away on a quiet lane just steps from Duval.

Caribbean RestaurantsSeafood Restaurants

Bagatelle is one of the most delicious restaurants on Duval Street and caters perfect meals for every occasion and time of the day. From mouthwatering omelets to sesame crusted seared tuna, Bagatelle also offers one of the most extensive wine lists on the island. Open for brunch and dinner, Bagatelle is the best place to get off of hot Duval and relax on the homey and elegant porch of a Victorian, architectural beauty.
Amigos Tortilla Bar

Mexican Restaurants

Amigos serves freshest, healthiest and tastiest tacos, quesadillas and burritos in Key West. Their tortilla dough is made fresh with a unique tortilla press that creates Amigos’ signature square shape using 100% ground corn —less spillage and more “yum” for you. You can watch them make them! Using spices used in Mexican and Central American meals since the Aztecs, the flavors are amazing. We think the guacamole is the best we have ever had!