search icon

Italian Restaurants

Bel Mare

Italian RestaurantsLocal Seafood

Bel Mare means ‘beautiful sea’ in Italian. That is exactly what you’ll experience when you dine with at Bel Mare. From the amazing views overlooking the historic Key West Bight to the beautifully fresh food that comes from that same ocean. Enjoy homemade pasta dishes, creatively crafted cocktails and an extensive wine list!
Lola's Bistro

Italian Restaurants

An Italian eclectic BYOB restaurant with a bohemian vibe!

Italian RestaurantsLocal Seafood

Abbondanza is located in the heart of Old Town Key West, Florida. Couples, friends and families alike enjoy the warm and inviting ambiance of their dining room and fun local energy of our bustling full liquor bar. Abbondanza has been the recipient for many years of the People's Choice Award for the best Italian Restaurant in Key West.
New York Pasta Garden

American RestaurantsBBQ and Soul Food

Established in 1989. The huge portions and creative cuisine quickly made New York Pasta Garden a favorite. The fresh seafood and friendly staff will keep you coming back for more!

DessertItalian Restaurants

Onlywood imported a massive brick oven made 100% from lavic materials coming from the Vesuvius in Napoli. It reaches 1000 degrees in temperature, which is a must for Neapolitan pizza style. They use 00 flower and the best tomato sauce, San Marzano, both imported from Italy, and make their own Mozzarella following an ancient recipe. They don’t forget to cook fresh local seafood and special plates that change every day, always with the Italian Style.
Antonia's Restaurant

American RestaurantsItalian Restaurants

A Key West landmark for locals and visitors alike for over 30 years! They proudly serve classic Italian cuisine, handmade pasta created in-house daily, finely crafted sauces, pristine local seafood, choice chops and steaks, decadent deserts, a Wine Spectator award-winning wine list representing the best of both the old world and the new, and a carefully curated full bar. Their menu showcases inventive meals, but never strays far away from the traditional homemade classics.
Roostica Wood Fire Pizzeria

Italian RestaurantsPizza Parlors

With its large wood burning, the aroma of Neopolitan pizza taste of the old country is alive in Key West. Roostica features mouthwatering red, white and stuffed pizzas using only the freshest ingredients. A large selection of crisp salads, antipasti and wine by the glass are a great way to start a meal. Don’t’ forget to try their famous Lemoncello wood fired wings, and on Sundays gravy and meatballs served family style.
La Tratorria Oceanside

Italian RestaurantsWaterfront Dining

Featuring the same delicious Italian cuisine and libations as the Old Town restaurant, La Tratorria Oceanside offers diners a taste of Italy overlooking the beautiful Atlantic Ocean.
La Trattorria

Italian Restaurants

La Tratorria offers an elegant taste of Italy in the Southernmost City. The elegant atmosphere is only exceeded by their extensive menu of Italian specialties such as antipasti, pastas baked lasagnas, meats and seafoods, all prepared to order. La Tratorria features one of the finest wine selections on the island.

Italian RestaurantsWaterfront Dining

Enjoyed by locals and guests alike, Salute! On The Beach offers fresh seafood, Italian classics, and savory salads. This lovely beach café is the perfect place for a combination of fine dining, great sights, and water activities all on Higgs Beach. Whether you’re dropping in for lunch, a swim, a delicious tropical drink or a sunset dinner, Salute! On The Beach is the ideal atmosphere for those seeking a true Key West experience.
Mangia Mangia

DeliveryItalian Restaurants

A favorite for both locals and visitors alike for delicious Italian fare with fresh, homemade pasta. They serve favorites like marinara and pesto and a Key West specialty, picadillo pasta. Seafood, salads and now gluten free pasta round out their menu, which can all be paired with something from their extensive wine list. Located on the corner of Southard and Margaret right smack dab in the heart of the Old Town neighborhood.

Ice Cream ShopsItalian Restaurants

If you’re a fan of real Italian pizza with crisp crusts and perfectly seasoned tomato sauce, or creamy cool gelato, then Duetto is the place for you. Offering the best pizzas, panini and gelato this side of Italy. Duetto iconveniently located just steps off of Duval Street, offers the most delicious Italian food this side of Rome for anyone craving a taste of Italy. Eat in, take out or call for delivery.